Why points change
Dynamic scoring from the player's side, covering decay, solve-time locking, and bloods.
A challenge was worth 500 points when you bookmarked it; now it says 340. Nothing is broken; most CTF challenges on Athena use dynamic scoring, where a challenge’s value falls as the event progresses. This page explains the system from where you’re standing: what moves, what’s locked, and how to play it.
The number you see is an offer, not a record
The points on a challenge card are what the next solver will earn: a live offer, refreshed as you browse. Two things can push it down, depending on the challenge’s scoring method:
- Solves (solve-rate scoring): every solve knocks the value down by a fixed percentage. The crowd is effectively rating the difficulty for you: a challenge half the field has solved ends up cheap, while one nobody has cracked keeps its price.
- Time (time-based scoring): the value slides continuously as time passes, counting from when the challenge was created (not from the event start), rewarding whoever gets there early regardless of how many others solve it.
Either way there’s a floor: organizers set a minimum below which the value never falls, so late solves are always worth something.
Your score is a record, not an offer
The moment you solve, the current value is yours, locked. Later solves and further decay lower the offer for future solvers, never your banked points. Your dashboard and profile always show the amount each solve earned at the time.
This is why two teams with identical solve lists can have different totals: the one who solved earlier caught each challenge at a higher price. It’s also the system’s core incentive: decay converts speed into points, without needing bonuses or multipliers.
Playing it well cuts both ways:
- On solve-rate challenges, watching the solve counter matters more than watching the clock. A challenge at 5 solves and falling is losing value fast; an untouched one will still be near full price tomorrow.
- On time-based challenges, the meter is always running; they’re the ones to prioritize early, because waiting costs points even if nobody else solves them.
The other ways your total moves
Decay explains the challenge values; a few more things shape the board itself:
- Hint penalties subtract points. Unlocking a paid hint subtracts its cost from your team’s score, once per team: a straightforward trade of points now for progress now. (You can’t go negative from a hint: one you can’t afford stays locked.)
- Organizers can adjust points directly. An organizer may award a bonus or apply a penalty to a team, with a reason attached. It changes the team’s total immediately, though it can’t push a team below zero.
- Bloods carry glory, not points. The 🥇 🥈 🥉 on the first three solves are recognition only; the first solver earns the same formula value as anyone solving at that moment. The real reward for being first is that the moment had the highest price.
- A removed challenge takes its points back. If organizers pull a challenge from the event entirely (usually because it was broken or shouldn’t have shipped), it disappears from the board along with your solve of it, and the points it awarded come off your total. Anything your team spent on its hints is refunded at the same time, so you are never left paying for a challenge that no longer exists. This is different from a challenge being temporarily locked, which never touches your score.
- A removed hint refunds what it cost. If organizers delete a hint (say it gave too much away), every team that unlocked it gets back exactly the points it spent.
- A deleted account takes its contribution with it. If an organizer deletes a player’s account, the points they personally earned from solves, and the hint penalties they personally triggered, are reversed off their team’s total. The rest of the roster’s work is untouched, and the reversal can’t push the team below zero. Simply leaving a team, or being removed from one, doesn’t move any points.
And when totals end up equal anyway, time settles it: the team that reached the shared score first ranks higher. Speed is baked into the ranking twice: once through decay, once through the tie-break.
Why design scoring this way?
Fixed-value scoring has a familiar failure mode: organizers guess difficulty in advance, misprice a challenge, and the event is decided by who farmed the mispriced one. Dynamic scoring lets the field correct the price during the event: difficulty is measured by actual solves and actual time, not by pre-event guesswork. The trade-off is the moving numbers this page just explained: values you can’t fully predict, in exchange for a board that reflects how hard things actually were.